Most “Investing” Is Just Speculation

The words people choose often reveal more about how they want to be perceived than what they're actually doing. Take the term "investing" - it implies not just sophistication and careful analysis, but also suggests a contribution to economic growth and societal progress.

"Investing" carries the noble implication of helping businesses expand, create jobs, and develop new products that benefit everyone.

But in reality, most activity labeled as "investing" today is really just speculation - an attempt to enrich oneself by buying and selling existing assets, rather than creating any new value for society.

The Real Meaning of Investment

True investment means providing capital to enterprises so they can grow, innovate, and create value. When someone invests in a company, they're directly contributing to economic growth - helping it build factories, hire employees, develop new products, or expand into new markets. This is genuine value creation that grows the economic pie for everyone. It happens when a company raises money through an Initial Public Offering (IPO) or issues new shares - they receive capital they can put to productive use, creating new jobs, products, and services that benefit society as a whole.

What Actually Happens in Markets

But that's not what happens in the vast majority of stock market activity. When someone buys shares of Apple or Tesla on their trading app, they're not giving money to those companies or directly contributing to economic growth. They're simply buying existing shares from another trader, hoping their price will go up so they can sell them to someone else later. This is, by definition, speculation - an attempt to capture more value for oneself rather than create new value for society. It's not growing the economic pie; it's just trying to get a bigger slice of the existing one.

Even large institutional investors, with their sophisticated algorithms and research departments, are essentially engaged in the same activity. They might call themselves "investment funds," but they're primarily trading existing assets on secondary markets, trying to profit from price movements rather than directly funding business growth.

Why This Distinction Matters

Now, this isn't to say that secondary market trading is useless. It serves crucial functions:

1. It provides liquidity, making it possible for people to buy and sell shares when they need to
2. It helps with price discovery, theoretically helping markets value assets efficiently
3. It creates the conditions that make primary market investment (actual investment) possible

Without active secondary markets, companies would struggle to raise capital through new share issuance, because investors would worry about being unable to sell their shares later.

Real Estate: Creation vs. Capture

The investment versus speculation distinction becomes particularly clear in real estate. When developers buy land, design projects, and construct new buildings, that's true investment - they're creating new living spaces, offices, or commercial venues that didn't exist before. This activity genuinely expands the housing supply, creates construction jobs, and adds real value to the economy.

In contrast, buying existing properties and holding them until their price increases is pure speculation. While speculators often claim they're "investing in real estate," they're not creating new housing or contributing to economic growth. They're simply betting on price appreciation and attempting to capture value from existing assets. Like stock market speculation, this activity might serve some market functions (providing liquidity, price discovery) but doesn't directly create new value for society.

Cryptocurrency: Pure Speculation

Cryptocurrency presents an even more striking case. Despite all the talk of "crypto investing," buying and holding cryptocurrencies is speculation in its purest form - there's rarely even the possibility of true investment. When someone buys Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies, they're not providing capital that can be used to create new products or services. They're simply hoping to sell their tokens later at a higher price to another buyer.

The only possible exceptions might be in specific cases where crypto projects are genuinely building new infrastructure or applications that add value to the economy - like developing more efficient payment systems or creating new technological platforms. But simply buying and holding crypto tokens, even if they're associated with such projects, remains speculation rather than investment. The token holder isn't directly funding development; they're betting on future price appreciation.

The Euphemism Game

The financial industry has masterfully rebranded trading and speculation as "investment," lending an air of respectability and sophistication to what is, in many cases, educated gambling. This isn't necessarily bad - speculation and trading are legitimate activities that can serve useful purposes. But calling everything "investment" obscures important distinctions and can lead to confused thinking about what's actually happening with capital flows.

A More Honest Approach

The financial world would benefit from more precise language:

• When buying new shares directly from a company, that's investment
• When buying existing shares hoping they'll appreciate, that's speculation
• When rapidly trading in and out of positions, that's trading
• When buying assets based on social media tips without analysis, that's gambling

There's room for all these activities in a healthy financial system. But understanding the differences between them helps create clearer thinking about financial choices and their relationship to the real economy.

The Way Forward

This isn't a call to stop buying shares or index funds - regular purchases of broad market index funds remain a sensible way to build long-term wealth. But it's important to understand that even this strategy is fundamentally speculative, betting that the overall market will continue to rise over time based on historical patterns.

What matters is intellectual honesty about these activities. There's no shame in speculation when it's done thoughtfully and with an understanding of the risks involved. The problem lies in pretending it's something more noble or sophisticated than it really is.

The next time someone talks about their "investments," it would be more accurate to say "I speculate in stocks," "I trade cryptocurrencies," or "I'm betting on the long-term growth of the global economy through index funds." It might not sound as impressive at dinner parties, but at least it's honest.

What I'm building

Delegate tasks. Get software.

Give Vroni a GitHub issue, bug report, spec, or rough idea. It reads the repo, plans the change, writes code, runs checks, and works toward a review-ready pull request.

Take a look at vroni.com