ETFs Are Inflating the Everything Bubble

Stock prices are at all-time highs and traditional valuation metrics like P/E ratios are largely ignored. At the same time, passive investing through ETF index funds has become the default advice: buy ETFs, hold forever, keep adding money every month.

Universal ETF AdoptionUniversal ETF Adoption

ETFs work great when only some people use them. In that scenario, active investors still analyze companies and trade based on fundamentals, which creates reasonable price discovery. Passive investors can then ride along, benefiting from the market's collective wisdom.

But when everyone buys ETFs, the mechanism breaks. ETFs don't analyze or make choices. When money flows into an S&P 500 ETF, it automatically buys all 500 stocks in their index weights. It doesn't matter if a company is trading at 300 times earnings or losing money. The ETF buys it anyway.

Feedback Loop

This creates a feedback loop. Money flows into ETFs, which pushes up all stock prices, which makes ETF returns look good, which attracts more money into ETFs. There's no natural stopping point because there's no mechanism for selling based on overvaluation. The buying is automatic and continuous through retirement accounts and savings plans.

Market Incentives

In a normal market, overvalued companies see their stock prices fall as investors sell. This creates winners and losers, and prices eventually reflect business fundamentals. But in an ETF-dominated market, every company in the index wins by default. Bad earnings? Doesn't matter, the ETF buying continues. Poor management? Still getting bought.

This removes the basic incentive structure of public markets. Why should companies focus on increasing earnings when their stock gets bought regardless? The whole point of stock prices is to reflect company value and performance. When that link breaks, we're not really investing anymore.

Passive Investing Paradox

The paradox is that passive investing only works if enough people are actively analyzing stocks. But active managers struggle to beat the index, partly because ETF flows keep pushing all prices up. So more people switch to passive, which makes the market less efficient, which makes the eventual problem worse.

What's Next

Maybe this continues indefinitely. Maybe P/E ratios stay permanently elevated because the buying never stops. After all, millions of people have automated investments. The money keeps flowing regardless of valuations.

But at some point, stock prices should reflect actual business earnings. If they don't, we're just betting that the next wave of automatic ETF purchases will be larger than the last. That's not investing. It's a game where everyone wins until they don't.

What I'm building

Delegate tasks. Get software.

Give Vroni a GitHub issue, bug report, spec, or rough idea. It reads the repo, plans the change, writes code, runs checks, and works toward a review-ready pull request.

Take a look at vroni.com